Farm Management
The United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) recently announced the election and enrollment deadlines for the Price Loss Coverage (PLC) and Agriculture Risk Coverage (ARC) programs for the 2026 and 2027 crop years. For the 2026 crop year, elections and enrollment are open through December 11, 2026. The 2027 decision period runs from November 2, 2026, through March 15, 2027. As farmers prepare to make these decisions, it is important to recognize that program election can have significant financial implications.
The PLC program is designed to stabilize income from low prices, while the ARC program covers revenue shortfalls from a combination of low prices and/or low yields. Making decisions related to these programs can often be difficult for farmers, and for some, their prior experiences with the programs can affect their decisions. Furthermore, when the enrolled program triggers a lower payment than the alternative, the payment received provides less income support than is optimal.
Introduction
To illustrate the challenges that farmers face in making optimal election decisions, the following information analyzes the PLC and ARC-County programs for the 2025 crop year. In 2025, farmers made decisions under the 2018 Farm Bill parameters prior to April 15, 2025. However, with the passage of the One Big Beautiful Bill Act (OB3) in July 2025, the PLC and ARC program payments for the 2025 crop year were changed to be based on the following:
- New reference prices
- An adjusted ARC formula
- The higher payment rate of PLC or ARC
The following focuses on the outcomes for five major crops—corn, peanuts, soybeans, wheat, and seed cotton—across the thirteen Southern states under the 2018 Farm Bill and under the changes introduced by OB3. For crops within a county that had both irrigated and nonirrigated ARC rates, the overall ARC rate was calculated as the weighted sum of the irrigated and nonirrigated ARC rates, using the respective percentages of irrigated and nonirrigated acreage. For counties and crops designated as all, the ARC rate was set equal to the corresponding ARC rate for all. There is no consideration of payment limits, because this analysis focuses strictly on county-level payment rates.
2018 Farm Bill Elections
The first part of this analysis illustrates the percentage of enrolled acres in each program in the Southern states that would have received the higher payment rate if the 2018 Farm Bill had still been in place for the 2025 crop year payments.
As shown in table 1, the total base acres across the South that were enrolled in the ARC program was 20,632,981 acres. Of this, 74.4 percent of the acreage is in counties where ARC would have received the higher payment rate under the 2018 Farm Bill. There are, however, vast differences across commodities. Nearly all of the soybean acres that enrolled in ARC would have received the higher payment. However, it is vastly less for corn and wheat, where only about two-thirds of the ARC enrolled acres would have received the higher payment. Only about one-third of ARC enrolled seed cotton and peanut base acres would have had the same outcome.
Meanwhile, the outcome for those that enrolled in PLC was less favorable, with only 51.1 percent of those base acres across the South receiving the higher payment rate. In other words, using 2018 Farm Bill parameters alone (without the OB3 improvements), 48.9 percent of the base acres enrolled in PLC would have been better off had it been enrolled in ARC for the 2025 crop year. Fortunately for these farmers, OB3 created the situation for the 2025 crop year where they will receive the higher of the ARC or PLC payment rate, regardless of their election.
Table 1. 2025 Base Acres Enrolled in ARC and PLC and Percentages Receiving Optimal Payment Rates Under 2018 Farm Bill
| Covered Commodity | Base Acres Enrolled in ARC | ARC-Enrolled Base Acres Where ARC Would Have Received the Higher Payment Rate (%) | Base Acres Enrolled in PLC | PLC-Enrolled Base Acres Where PLC Would Have Received the Higher Payment Rate (%) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Corn | 5,699,520 | 62.2 | 2,028,292 | 52.1 |
| Peanuts | 23,417 | 39.2 | 2,253,098 | 51.3 |
| Seed cotton | 1,324,425 | 30.5 | 9,567,675 | 61.3 |
| Soybeans | 6,586,209 | 99.8 | 566,848 | 10.0 |
| Wheat | 6,999,410 | 68.9 | 7,466,245 | 40.8 |
| Total | 20,632,981 | 74.4 | 21,882,157 | 51.1 |
Payments Under the One Big Beautiful Bill Act
The second part of this analysis focuses on the higher of the ARC or PLC payment rates under the OB3 changes. In this case, the actual enrollment decision does not matter. Figure 1 shows county maps for the selected commodities. Counties shaded in green indicate when the PLC payment rate was higher, and counties shaded in red indicate when the ARC payment rate was higher.
For corn and soybeans, the majority of the counties where base acres exist received a higher payment rate under the ARC program. However, there are large areas in Texas, North Carolina, and Virginia where the PLC program triggered the higher payment rate for corn. Meanwhile, peanuts, seed cotton, and wheat are predominantly being paid under PLC, although areas of Kentucky, Tennessee, and Alabama have many counties where ARC triggered the higher payment rate for wheat.
This illustrates the potential under all crops for farmers in a given county to benefit more from one program compared to the other. It is also important to note that this analysis is at the county level. While ARC payments for a covered commodity are the same for all farmers in a county, PLC payments vary based on an individual producer’s PLC yield.

Figure 1. County maps illustrating the higher of the ARC or PLC payment rates under the One Big Beautiful Bill Act
Payment Differences Between ARC and PLC
Enrolling in a program that does not generate the maximum payment rate results in a smaller safety net. To quantify the additional payment rate that would result from receiving the higher of the ARC or PLC payment rate, one needs to calculate the payment difference between the higher payment and the alternative.
Figure 2 reports these differences using payment rates calculated under the OB3 provisions. Payment differences vary considerably, with additional payment rates more than $350 per base acre for a crop in one county. Smaller additional payment rates were more common. A total of 59.2 percent of the differences were less than $44.30 per base acre. Although only 9.5 percent were under $5 per base acre. This means that if farmers had to make a choice in 2025 under the new OB3 provisions and they made a choice that did not maximize payments, the payment difference would have been more than $44 per base acre more than 40 percent of the time.

Figure 2. Distribution of 2025 crop year payment rate differences (higher payment rate minus alternative payment rate) under the One Big Beautiful Bill Act
Conclusion
This analysis indicates the potential payment inefficiencies farmers may face when needing to choose between the ARC and PLC programs. The additional payments can have significant financial implications in covering farm income during times of financial struggles because of low prices or revenue shortfalls. Without changes in legislation, it is important for farmers to take the time to make an informed decision regarding their ARC and PLC elections.
Farmers should understand the fundamental differences between the ARC and PLC programs:
- PLC provides price support and triggers payments when the marketing year average price falls below the effective reference price.
- ARC provides revenue support and triggers when revenue falls below a guaranteed revenue level. Revenue is determined by county yield (not individual yield for ARC-County) and marketing year average prices.
Consequently, if farmers expect prices to decline while yield remains stable, the PLC program might be the optimal choice if prices are expected to be low enough to trigger a payment. If a decline in county yields is expected, particularly when accompanied by lower prices, the ARC program may provide a higher payment.
Several decision guides are available to assist in making decisions, such as the Texas A&M Agricultural and Food Policy Center Decision Tool. Even though no decision tool can guarantee the maximum payment, these resources can provide useful information for evaluating the relative advantages of both programs. In addition to using a decision guide, farmers should consider both their price and yield expectations and the information that is available to them for the crop year when evaluating which program may provide a greater farm safety net.
This Extension Brief was edited from the original peer-reviewed version published by the same authors in Southern Ag Today (October 12, 2026).