They are widely
feared as two of the worst diseases imaginable -- the equivalent of
a death sentence for animals and humans alike.
Yet, no trace of the animal disease, Bovine
Spongiform Encepathalopathy (BSE) -- also known as mad cow disease
-- has been detected in the United States. Neither has its human
counterpart, Creutzfeldt Jakob disease (CJD), associated with
consuming meat and meat products. Based on the findings of a recent
Harvard study, this is likely to remain the case for the foreseeable
future.
The study confirms that banning meat and bone meal
in animal feed -- a measure imposed by the cattle industry years ago
to prevent the spread of mad cow disease into the United States --
is the prime defense against the disease. For this reason, the study
concludes the chances of mad cow ever posing a threat to U.S. cattle
– and ultimately humans in the form of CJD -- are remote.
The study is based on reviews of American and
European prevention programs, data on the spread of the disease
throughout Europe, and surveys of meat-processing practices in the
United States. Its findings support what many experts have suspected
for a long time: outbreaks of mad cow disease in Europe stemmed from
the once common European practice of feeding cattle with offal –
in this case, sheep renderings containing brain and spinal tissue.
More recent outbreaks in Britain have been attributed to the use of
bone meal in feed.
Neither of these feeding practices has ever been
used in the United States.
Though they are not yet completely certain how the
disease occurs, scientists believe the culprit behind both diseases
is an aberrant protein known as a prion, which European cattle
presumably ingested from sheep offal and later from bone meal.
"We’re not quite sure what these proteins
really are and even how they reach the brain," says Dr. Jean
Weese, Alabama Cooperative Extension food scientist. "All we
know is that they are not living things, like bacteria, although
they concentrate in the brain like a toxin."
Equally baffling to scientists is the fact that
these prions are virtually impervious to heat.
Testing, for example, shows that prions remain
intact at temperatures as high as 2000 degrees Celsius, Weese says.
Even so, Weese says, people shouldn’t worry about
mad cow disease or it’s human equivalent, CJD.
Even in Europe, where outbreaks have occurred, one
is far more likely to be struck by lightening than to contract the
disease, Weese says. In fact, only about 100 people have died from
CJD since the outbreaks first occurred in Europe more than 4 years
ago.
Studies have shown death from exposure to prions
associated with CJD is far less likely to occur than from food
pathogens such as listeria, salmonella and E.coli 0157:H7. Even
deaths from food pathogens are very few, Weese says.
For example, listeriosis, associated with
contaminated meats, dairy products and raw vegetables, and
salmonella, most often linked with raw eggs, cause slightly more
than 500 deaths a year in the United States – out of a population
of almost 300 million.
The risk of mad cow disease is likely to be even
more remote in the future: Auburn University researchers are
developing tests that will detect any animal tissue in livestock
feed that has been linked with mad cow disease.
(Source: Dr. Jean
Weese, Extension Food Scientist, 334-844-3269.)