Auburn, March 15---Dietary supplements are
fraught with risk, experts say.
It
is a fact reflected in the lives of three women whose
lives have been permanently changed because of supplement
use.
One American woman suffered permanent liver damage,
while the other two, both Swedish, developed unwanted
pregnancies after using herbal supplements.
What many people often overlook is the fact that many
supplements considered "natural" and
"safe" actually may contain all sorts of
substances, even prescription drugs that interfere with
other drugs or produce long-term, even life-threatening,
health problems.
"When you take these supplements, you really don’t
know what you’re getting," says Dr. Robert Keith,
an Alabama Cooperative Extension System nutritionist.
This is because the supplement industry, unlike the
drug industry, is largely unregulated, and supplements do
not have to be tested prior to release, he says.
"With a prescription drug, you pretty much know
what you’re getting in the way of possible side effects
and interactions with other drugs, because these drugs
have been rigorously tested prior to release," Keith
says. "But with supplements, you’re talking about a
product that can be released before any tests are
made."
The three women learned this fact the hard way. The
45-year-old woman suffering permanent liver damage became
so seriously ill within a few months that doctors
concluded she will need a liver transplant to survive.
Prior to her illness, she was consuming Kava, a popular
herbal drink that supposedly relieves stress by producing
a sense of calmness.
European health authorities report 25 similar cases of
liver damage associated with kava use. The supplement
already has been banned in some countries, even though
kava parties and even bars are the rage throughout the
United States.
Sweden’s pharmaceutical regulator also issued a
warning about herbal supplements after two Swedish women
developed unwanted pregnancies from consuming St. John’s
wort, which is often used to relieve mild forms of
depression.
The women, aged 28 and 32, were not aware St. John’s
wort can interfere with hormone-based contraceptives. St.
John’s wort is also believed to reduce the effectiveness
of other drugs, including HIV medicines, blood thickening
drugs and cyclosporine, used to prevent the rejection of
organ transplants.
Nevertheless, many countries, including the United
States, do not require supplement manufacturers to carry
label warnings about these popular interactions.
Other supplements may even contain traces of
prescription drugs, such as warfarin, a powerful blood
anticoagulant.
Keith suspects anti-depressants and anti-anxiety drugs
are among several types of substances put into supplements
merely to trick buyers into believing they are getting a
big bang for their bucks.
"I can’t think of any other reason why they
would put these drugs in a product unless they were trying
to create some biological effect, so that people using
these products would actually think they are
working," he says.
In many cases, supplement manufacturers are often able
to go undetected for years unless someone gets sick
consuming their products.
Even in cases where products do not contain harmful
substances, it is possible consumers are not getting what
is advertised on the label.
Testing by Consumer Reports, for example,
revealed that roughly 25 percent of these supplement
products may not contain the concentration of the herb or
supplement advertised on the product label.
"It’s just like the Old West when saloon owners
watered down their drinks to inflate their profits,"
Keith says. "Without regulatory oversight, many
supplement manufacturers have a strong incentive do the
same thing, because, after all, who is watching
them?"
Keith offers this advice to consumers. First, when
buying supplements, buy only name-brand products. Big
companies have their reputation invested in these products
and, therefore, have less incentive to tamper with them.
Likewise, avoid products produced by obscure companies.
"In some cases, these may not be
"companies" at all, but one-person outfits
operating out of, say, a vacant garage," Keith says.
Second, stick with nutrients, such as vitamins C and E
and folic acid, and avoid many herbal supplements
entirely, especially exotic supplements that appear to
make fantastic claims.
(Source: Dr. Robert
Keith, Extension Nutritionist, 334-844-3273.)